The Truth Behind Animal Rights Organizations
In today’s world, many people want to do good. They want to help animals, protect their well-being, and support causes that matter. But good intentions can sometimes lead us down the wrong path—especially when we don’t stop to ask where our money is going and what beliefs we’re actually supporting.
It’s time to take a closer look at some of the most well-known animal rights organizations and ask the hard questions: What do they really stand for? And are their values aligned with yours as a responsible animal owner?
PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals) is often the first organization people think of when they hear “animal rights.” But what most don’t realize is that PETA holds an extremist stance on animal ownership itself. Their core belief is that animals are not ours to own, train, ride, eat, or even share our lives with. That’s right—they oppose the very concept of pet ownership, even when animals are well cared for and loved like family. They have publicly advocated for the end of all domesticated animals and, controversially, have euthanized a large percentage of animals that pass through their care—even adoptable ones.
Then there’s the ASPCA (American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals). While many assume donations to the ASPCA help local shelters, the reality is that very little of their funding actually reaches local communities. Most of it is funneled into national advertising and lobbying efforts that push for sweeping legislation—often out of touch with the needs of responsible pet owners, breeders, and working-dog communities.
And while we’re on it the Humane Society of the United States (HSUS) often gets lumped into the same category. Despite the name, HSUS is not affiliated with local humane societies or shelters, and their actions have, at times, worked against responsible breeders, trainers, and agricultural animal stewards.
Extremism vs. Responsible Ownership
Here’s the truth no one wants to say out loud: Not all “animal rights” groups actually care about animals the way you or I do. There’s a vast difference between animal rights and animal welfare. The former often centers around an ideological belief that animals should live completely free from human interaction, while the latter focuses on humane treatment, responsible care, and ethical ownership.
As a dog trainer, I’ve seen firsthand the deep, meaningful bonds that form between people and animals. I’ve worked with owners who are fiercely committed to their dogs—teaching them, protecting them, and honoring the animal for what it is. Responsible ownership means providing structure, medical care, enrichment, and, yes, even discipline when needed. That’s not cruelty—it’s respect.
The problem with many mainstream “animal rights” groups is they demonize any human-animal relationship that doesn’t fit their rigid ideals. Whether it’s a farmer working livestock, a police department utilizing K9 units, or a family using an e-collar to communicate more clearly with their dog—if it doesn’t fit the narrative, it’s condemned.
Where Should You Put Your Support?
If you truly care about animal welfare, support your local shelter or rescue group directly. Support responsible breeders. Ask them where your donations go. Volunteer. Foster. Adopt or Shop responsibly. Support trainers and professionals who put animals' physical and emotional needs first. Promote thoughtful legislation, not blanket bans or fear-driven campaigns.
And most importantly—do your research before donating to any large-scale organization with a polished name and a sad-eyed commercial.
If you're unsure about an organization or looking for local groups to support, feel free to reach out. I’m happy to connect you with trainers, rescues, and advocates who walk the walk, not just talk the talk.